I do not consider it a "problem" that the prisoners at Guantanamo still retain their identities. Given the type of psychological torment require to deconstruct a person's sense of self, I would not even make a joke of it. The fact that the prisoners routinely attack their guards actually supports Tietz's article. To answer your question of what they have to lose, the answer is their lives. Either they're still attempting to become martyrs, or they see no way out other than death. The civilian term for it is police-assisted suicide. Why might they be driven to this? Because, as Tietz states in his article, there are no clearly defined exit criteria that would end their incarceration. Thus, to answer my own question of what they have to gain, religious salvation or freedom from crushing uncertainty and despair.
Few Guantanamo detainees have been proven to have more than the most tenuous connections to terrorist organizations. While their commitment to the destruction of the West prior to their incarceration is uncertain, their incarceration has undoubtedly strengthened their hatred for the West. I could not even begin to posit a solution for this situation. However, without evidence, we can't fairly prosecute them. Without fair prosecution and defense, there can be no justice. If we deal with these men unjustly, than that thin line that separates the terrorists from us becomes that much more faint. We can't change the rules just because we don't like the outcome.
I have some hopes for the Military Commissions Act in terms of prevention. However, I also strongly feel that the US needs to definitively investigate the conditions at Guantanamo during the 2001-2004 period. We need to shine the harsh light of truth on the murky history of this prison and face the vindication or damnation that will be revealed. Only then can we move on as a nation and only then can we regain some of the international and domestic credibility we've lost over this situation. If a stain on our national honor is revealed, then we must also atone as a nation. The semblance or rhetoric of righteouness isn't enough. We need to be righteous in order to shine.
no subject
Few Guantanamo detainees have been proven to have more than the most tenuous connections to terrorist organizations. While their commitment to the destruction of the West prior to their incarceration is uncertain, their incarceration has undoubtedly strengthened their hatred for the West. I could not even begin to posit a solution for this situation. However, without evidence, we can't fairly prosecute them. Without fair prosecution and defense, there can be no justice. If we deal with these men unjustly, than that thin line that separates the terrorists from us becomes that much more faint. We can't change the rules just because we don't like the outcome.
I have some hopes for the Military Commissions Act in terms of prevention. However, I also strongly feel that the US needs to definitively investigate the conditions at Guantanamo during the 2001-2004 period. We need to shine the harsh light of truth on the murky history of this prison and face the vindication or damnation that will be revealed. Only then can we move on as a nation and only then can we regain some of the international and domestic credibility we've lost over this situation. If a stain on our national honor is revealed, then we must also atone as a nation. The semblance or rhetoric of righteouness isn't enough. We need to be righteous in order to shine.